The black coating rubs off pretty quickly. It doesn’t look broken in or well-loved. It looks like those cheap, colored carabiners do after a few weeks of use. If that will bother you, I’d go with the silver. They will not exchange it for you later - I asked. Also, the bottle opener is a pain

Yeah, $60 is a lot for a carabiner. But when you get this after ordering it, you’ll understand exactly why. It feels solid and sturdy, like the MacBook of carabiners. It’s sleek. It’s functional and I use it to pop open a gratuitous amount of Topo Chicos on the daily. Get it. It’ll be the last carabiner you ever need.

Rugged and utilitarian. Very nice product!

Your keys cannot accidentally fall off of this key ring.

I recently purchased the Mehlville and it is exactly what I was looking for. Now I can quickly switch between sets of keys and feel much more organized as a result. It doesn't hurt that this is also a great looking product, 5 stars for style. As a James myself, I approve this product.

Looking forward to getting a knife as well, likely one of the Carters! Love the brand!